Get the MovieNight app
Add it to your home screen — faster & full screen
Get the MovieNight app
Add it to your home screen — faster & full screen
Not part of a collection.
In this stylish caper, Peter and Audrey must master the art of the "fake-flirt" and the high-stakes swap to steal a $10 million masterpiece and settle a debt with a vengeful mob boss.
In the high-stakes sequel How to Replace a Heart, the fallout from their previous heist catches up with Peter and Audrey when they are hunted down by the ruthless Ms. Bridger and a disgruntled bodyguard. To settle a massive debt and recover a stolen necklace, the pair is forced into a daring new operation: stealing a "real" masterpiece from the private collection of a wealthy divorcée named Grace. Working alongside their former adversaries, they infiltrate a Lake Washington gala undercover as cater-waiters, utilizing a complex diversion involving a wine-drenched painting and a timed security reset. While Peter distracts the mark with a calculated "fake-flirtation," Audrey orchestrates a seamless swap of the multimillion-dollar artwork. However, as they deliver the prize to clear their names, they remain unaware that their target is already planning a personal vendetta. This slick follow-up blends romantic tension with a double-crossing caper where no one's heart—or art—is truly safe.
Geena Pietromonaco
Audrey
Jon Meggison
Peter
Corryn Gutierrez
Grace
No crew information available.
Voicemails for Isabelle
To Be or Not to Be
A Grand Day Out
Antoine and Colette
The Woodsman
The Drayton Case
Monsoon Wedding
Julian
Party Central
The Day I Met You
Canada Vignettes: The Egg
Fabrizio’s Initiation
The Insatiable Mrs. Kirsch
Souvenir
Pvrgatorivm
Gummiboot
Siri
Calling Scotland Yard: Falstaff's Fur Coat
The Desire to See a Film of Rainer Werner Fassbinder
Vidiots
Risqué
Hostile Takeover
Accident Man: Hitman's Holiday
22 Jump Street
Red Notice
Trap House
Fun with Dick and Jane
2 Guns
The Pickup
Eenie Meanie
Accident Man
Bottle Rocket
Bulletproof 2
Stark Raving Mad
The Protector
Die Hart
The Kill Room
Sheroes
How to Rob a Bank
Chain of Fools
© 2025-2026 MovieNight. All rights reserved.
Versus
Sign in to play →
The Cameraman
2011
Denise
2016
Sign in to vote
Battle your watched movies head-to-head
Community Top Movies
Evil Dead II
1987 · 14 wins
The Dark Knight
2008 · 14 wins
Halloween
1978 · 13 wins
Final Destination
2000 · 12 wins
Halloween II
1981 · 11 wins
Trivia
Leaderboard →Playing as a guest — sign in to save your score and rank on the leaderboard.
Movie Trivia
Guess the movie from a clue — tagline, plot, cast and more. Pick from four posters.
What movie experience do you prefer?
What is your favorite movie genre?
Versus
Sign in to play →
The Cameraman
2011
Denise
2016
Sign in to vote
Battle your watched movies head-to-head
Community Top Movies
Evil Dead II
1987 · 14 wins
The Dark Knight
2008 · 14 wins
Halloween
1978 · 13 wins
Final Destination
2000 · 12 wins
Halloween II
1981 · 11 wins
Trivia
Leaderboard →Playing as a guest — sign in to save your score and rank on the leaderboard.
Movie Trivia
Guess the movie from a clue — tagline, plot, cast and more. Pick from four posters.
What movie experience do you prefer?
What is your favorite movie genre?
We use essential cookies to run MovieNight, plus analytics (Google Analytics) and advertising (Google AdSense) cookies. By continuing to browse, you agree to this — or click No and we won't. See our Terms & Privacy Policy to learn more.