MovieNight.app
I Used to Be Funny
?
Barn 12
Crave Crave

Not part of a collection.

I Used to Be Funny

2024 106 min ★ 6.7 (66) Released
Comedy Drama

Sam, an aspiring stand-up comedian and au pair struggling with PTSD, weighs whether to join the search for Brooke, a missing teenage girl she used to nanny. As she fights to recover from her trauma and return to the stage, memories of her deep bond with Brooke rush back—making it impossible to ignore her disappearance.

Original title
I Used to Be Funny
Language
EN
Country
CA
Budget
$2,000,000
Revenue
$160,499
Reviews & Ratings 1
L

Louisa Moore - Screen Zealots

Jul 17, 2024 · via TMDB

★ 6.0

With “I Used to Be Funny,” writer / director Ally Pankiw intertwines mystery and emotional depth to create a compelling narrative in her dark dramedy about a missing teenage girl and her friendship with a stand-up comedian with a debilitating case of PTSD. By exploring the various complexities of trauma, recovery, and healing in a refreshing, honest way, the film is poignant and feels highly personal. This is a story of emotional suffering, fractured relationships, and the long-term process of reclaiming happiness and a sense of identity. Revealing too much of the plot will spoil the film, so this review will be as vague as possible. Sam (Rachel Sennott) is an aspiring comedian who works as an au pair for Brooke (Olga Petsa). Told in flashbacks over a span of the last two years, the story begins with a news report that Brooke has gone missing. Sam, who is suffering from a traumatic event, decides to join in the search for the girl she used to nanny. Blending the past and present, it becomes clear why these two women are dealing with emotional wounds in their own unique way. This is the perfect vehicle for Sennott to showcase her range as an actor, and she delivers a powerful performance. she captures the complexity of her character with nuance, blending drama with a touch of comedy when her situation becomes too much to bear. While her story isn’t on its own very original, Pankiw is an outstanding storyteller, shifting seamlessly between the past and present. The dual timeline keeps the narrative unpredictable and surprising, which will keep you engaged during the film’s slower moments (it could use some tightening overall). The challenging subject matter can feel upsetting and heartbreaking, but it’s also so important to see stories that highlight essential aspects of the female experience. Sam and Brooke have a loving yet complicated relationship, and Pankiw explores this friendship with a heart-wrenching candor. “I Used to Be Funny” isn’t a film that’s easy to watch, but it gives a highly realistic portrayal of the slow and agonizing healing process after living through a traumatic experience. By: Louisa Moore / SCREEN ZEALOTS

User reviews courtesy of TMDB.

Keywords 17
candid comedian compassionate disheartening earnest female protagonist intimate melancholy missing girl nanny post-traumatic stress disorder (ptsd) sentimental sexual assault toronto, canada tragic understated woman director
Buy
Amazon Video Amazon Video
Apple TV Store Apple TV Store
Fandango At Home Fandango At Home
Streaming
Netflix Netflix
Amazon Prime Video Amazon Prime Video
Netflix Standard with Ads Netflix Standard with Ads
Amazon Prime Video with Ads Amazon Prime Video with Ads
Rent
Amazon Video Amazon Video
Apple TV Store Apple TV Store
Fandango At Home Fandango At Home
Pijama Films Pijama Films
Cast 19
Rachel Sennott

Rachel Sennott

Sam Cowell

Olga Petsa

Olga Petsa

Brooke Renner

Jason Jones

Jason Jones

Cameron Renner

Sabrina Jalees

Sabrina Jalees

Paige

Caleb Hearon

Caleb Hearon

Philip

Ennis Esmer

Ennis Esmer

Noah

Dani Kind

Dani Kind

Jill

Hoodo Hersi

Hoodo Hersi

Zara

Dan Beirne

Dan Beirne

Tim

Stephen Alexander

Stephen Alexander

Nathan

Miguel Rivas

Miguel Rivas

Officer Conrad Lawrence

Marvin Kaye

Marvin Kaye

Officer Jim Gerrard

Kathy Imrie

Kathy Imrie

Judge Mathers

Janice Mendes

Janice Mendes

Female Police Officer

Matia Jackett

Matia Jackett

Candace

Daniel Woodrow

Daniel Woodrow

Waiter

D.J. Mausner

D.J. Mausner

School Receptionist

Anna Vlachos

Anna Vlachos

News Anchor

Hannah Spear

Hannah Spear

Laura Renner

Crew 8
Ally Pankiw

Ally Pankiw

Director

Emma Jean Sutherland

Emma Jean Sutherland

First Assistant Director

Curt Lobb

Curt Lobb

Editor

Ally Pankiw

Ally Pankiw

Executive Producer

Jordan Nahmias

Jordan Nahmias

Executive Producer

Kate Fenton

Kate Fenton

Production Manager

Ames Bessada

Ames Bessada

Original Music Composer

Ally Pankiw

Ally Pankiw

Writer

Gallery 49
Videos 2
Similar Movies 216
Recommended 57
US Release Dates 11

Mar 13, 2023

South by Southwest Film & TV Festival

Premiere

Sep 28, 2023

Woodstock Film Festival

Premiere

Oct 1, 2023

Crested Butte Film Festival

Premiere

Oct 2, 2023

Nashville Film Festival

Premiere

Oct 14, 2023

New Hampshire Film Festival

Premiere

Oct 15, 2023

Newport Beach Film Festival

Premiere

Oct 21, 2023

Philadelphia Film Festival

Premiere

Jun 7, 2024

New York City, NY

Theatrical (Limited)

Jun 14, 2024

Theatrical (Limited)

Jun 18, 2024

NR Digital

Sep 5, 2024

Netflix

R Digital

© 2025-2026 MovieNight. All rights reserved.

Youth Is Over

Youth Is Over

VS
Thomas & Friends: The Great Bubbly Build

Thomas & Friends: The Great Bubbly Build

2023

Sign in to vote

Battle your watched movies head-to-head

Community Top Movies

🥇 Evil Dead II

Evil Dead II

1987 · 14 wins

🥈 The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight

2008 · 14 wins

🥉 Final Destination

Final Destination

2000 · 12 wins

#4 Top Gun: Maverick

Top Gun: Maverick

2022 · 11 wins

#5 Joker

Joker

2019 · 11 wins

Sign in to build your own ranking
0 Points
0/0 Correct
0 Streak

Playing as a guest — sign in to save your score and rank on the leaderboard.

Movie Trivia

Guess the movie from a clue — tagline, plot, cast and more. Pick from four posters.

What movie experience do you prefer?

Movie theater — theater popcorn with Icee/soda & maybe nachos 100%
At home — relaxed on your favorite couch or chair with whatever drinks & snacks are in the kitchen 0%
2 votes

What is your favorite movie genre?

Action 0%
Adventure 0%
Animation 0%
Comedy 0%
Crime 0%
Documentary 0%
Drama 0%
Family 0%
Fantasy 0%
History 0%
Horror 100%
Music 0%
Mystery 0%
Romance 0%
Science Fiction 0%
Thriller 0%
War 0%
Western 0%
2 votes
MovieNight
Home Browse Trending Top 100s Keywords Streaming Weekly Picks Blog Watchlist Trivia Guess the Movie Face-Off Watch Tonight Double Feature Birthday Movies MovieNight 100 Community This Day in Movies Ever thought, what to watch? Tops In Theaters Coming Soon New Releases
Youth Is Over

Youth Is Over

VS
Thomas & Friends: The Great Bubbly Build

Thomas & Friends: The Great Bubbly Build

2023

Sign in to vote

Battle your watched movies head-to-head

Community Top Movies

🥇 Evil Dead II

Evil Dead II

1987 · 14 wins

🥈 The Dark Knight

The Dark Knight

2008 · 14 wins

🥉 Final Destination

Final Destination

2000 · 12 wins

#4 Top Gun: Maverick

Top Gun: Maverick

2022 · 11 wins

#5 Joker

Joker

2019 · 11 wins

Sign in to build your own ranking
0 Points
0/0 Correct
0 Streak

Playing as a guest — sign in to save your score and rank on the leaderboard.

Movie Trivia

Guess the movie from a clue — tagline, plot, cast and more. Pick from four posters.

What movie experience do you prefer?

Movie theater — theater popcorn with Icee/soda & maybe nachos 100%
At home — relaxed on your favorite couch or chair with whatever drinks & snacks are in the kitchen 0%
2 votes

What is your favorite movie genre?

Action 0%
Adventure 0%
Animation 0%
Comedy 0%
Crime 0%
Documentary 0%
Drama 0%
Family 0%
Fantasy 0%
History 0%
Horror 100%
Music 0%
Mystery 0%
Romance 0%
Science Fiction 0%
Thriller 0%
War 0%
Western 0%
2 votes

We use essential cookies to run MovieNight, plus analytics (Google Analytics) and advertising (Google AdSense) cookies. By continuing to browse, you agree to this — or click No and we won't. See our Terms & Privacy Policy to learn more.